It Took 87 Messages and a Poll for My Group Chat to Pick a Brunch Spot (We Canceled)

My group chat spent four days, 87 messages, and one formal poll deciding on brunch. We canceled the morning of. This is our love language.

Picture this: It's a Tuesday night. I'm in bed, doing that thing where I scroll TikTok while a podcast plays in the background like some kind of digital triple-shot espresso. My phone buzzes. It's Hannah. The message? Five words that would consume the next 96 hours of my life:

"We should do brunch soon!"

Reader, we did not do brunch soon. We did not do brunch at all. But oh, what a journey it was.

The Innocent Spark That Ignited a Bureaucratic Inferno

Here's the thing about "we should do brunch soon!" — it's not a plan. It's a prayer. A wish whispered into the void of iMessage, hoping someone else will turn it into an actual event with a date and a Yelp link and a confirmed headcount.

And in our group of seven, someone always does. That someone is Hannah. Bless her heart. Hannah is a Planner with a capital P, and within 11 minutes of her opening message, she'd already pivoted into logistics mode: "What about this Saturday?? Or next?? Or the one after??"

Cue 87 messages. Which, honestly, feels low for us. Apparently I'm not alone in this digital chaos — more than half of Gen Z smartphone users say their group chat knows more about their daily lives than their families do, and 79% share major life updates with the group chat before their families. So really, our brunch debate was less "logistics" and more "intimate sharing of our deepest scheduling traumas." Romantic, even.

The Scheduling Matrix From Hell

Seven women. Zero overlapping free Saturdays. I cannot stress this enough — zero.

• Hannah had a wedding (not hers)
• Megan had a wedding (also not hers)
• Priya was "tentatively free but might be in Connecticut??"
• Jess works every other weekend and could never remember which weekend was which
• Caro had a half-marathon she'd been "training for" (read: mentioning)
• Liv just said "depends" with no further context
• And I, your humble narrator, had absolutely nothing going on but pretended to "check my calendar" for 40 minutes so I didn't seem available and desperate

This is, I've learned, completely on-brand for adulthood. Turns out nearly 60% of Americans cancel social plans at least once a month, often citing stress or anxiety. Which makes sense, because just looking at our shared availability gave me hives.

A Loving Taxonomy of Group Chat Personalities

Every group chat is a sociological case study, and ours is no different. Let me introduce you to the cast:

The Poll Creator (Hannah): When messages crossed 40 and we still had no consensus, Hannah deployed the nuclear option: a formal iMessage poll. With emojis. With time slots. With a deadline. I respect her. I fear her. I would die for her.

The Thumbs-Up-Only Reactor (Megan): Megan has not typed a real sentence in the group chat since approximately March. She communicates exclusively through tapbacks. A 👍 on the date. A ❤️ on the restaurant suggestion. A 😂 at someone's unrelated screenshot. Is she even alive? Unclear. But she is engaged.

The 48-Hour Ghost (Liv): Liv goes silent for two full days while we hash out every detail — venue, time, parking, whether mimosas are included — and then resurfaces at hour 49 with: "wait what if we did Cafe Mogador instead??" Cafe Mogador was not on the table. Cafe Mogador has never been on the table. We have to start over. We always start over.

The Veto Specialist (Caro): More on her in a moment.

The Enthusiastic But Useless (me, probably): I send "omg yes!!!!" to every suggestion and then contribute nothing of substance. I am the cheerleader of chaos.

The Venue Debate Spiral (or: When Caro Discovered She Was Suddenly Gluten-Free)

This is the part of group brunch planning that scientists should really study. We landed on a restaurant — a cute little place with $14 avocado toast and a wait list that takes your dignity. Everyone reacted with a thumbs up. Even Megan! A miracle!

And then.

Caro: "wait is this place gluten free friendly? i've been trying to cut back 🥲"

Reader. Reader. I have watched this woman demolish three slices of pizza at 2 a.m. I have witnessed her order pasta carbonara with extra bread. The gluten sensitivity was, shall we say, news to us.

But this is the nature of group decisions! Apparently larger groups suffer from "process loss" — the more people involved, the more coordination effort balloons, the more random objections derail everything, and the more likely it is that someone will suddenly announce a dietary restriction that did not exist 20 minutes ago. Science!

We pivoted. Three new restaurants. Two more polls. One impassioned monologue from Priya about the ambiance of a place in Bushwick. Megan thumbs-upped everything indiscriminately. Liv suggested Cafe Mogador again. We ignored her.

By Friday night, we had a venue. We had a time. We had a reservation. We had triumphed.

The Morning-Of Cascade (and the Suspicious Wave of Relief)

Saturday, 9:14 a.m. I am putting on mascara with the grim determination of a soldier going to war.

9:16 a.m. — Jess: "you guys i am SO sorry but i think i'm coming down with something 😷"

9:19 a.m. — Caro: "omg same energy honestly, my run wrecked me yesterday"

9:23 a.m. — Priya: "ok wait if jess and caro can't go......"

9:24 a.m. — Hannah (devastated, brave): "should we just reschedule?? 🥲"

9:24 a.m. — Megan: 👍

9:25 a.m. — Me, already taking off my jeans: "no worries at all!! next time!! ❤️❤️❤️"

The relief, my friends. The relief. I climbed back into bed with the speed of a woman who had narrowly escaped something terrible, like jury duty or a family dinner. And I know — I know — every single one of them did the same thing. There's research suggesting that people commit to plans when they're abstract and in the future but want to bail once the concrete effort becomes salient — i.e., when "Saturday brunch" stops being a fun idea and becomes "put on a bra and take the train." Guilty. So guilty.

The Two-Week Silence (and the Inevitable Resurrection)

The chat went dark. Not "everyone's mad" dark — more like "we collectively need to recover" dark. Two whole weeks of nothing but Megan reacting to old messages and Liv sending a single TikTok of a dog.

And then, like clockwork, at 11:47 p.m. on a Wednesday, Hannah typed it:

"okay but we should ACTUALLY do brunch soon"

And we all reacted with hearts. And the cycle began again. Amen.

---

So tell me: how many messages does YOUR group chat need to pick a restaurant? And be honest — truly honest — were you a little bit relieved when it got canceled?

I'll wait. I'll be in bed. With my bra off.